Friday, October 30, 2009

The Travel Troubleshooter: Tarmac Delays Ground the Fight for Passenger Rights

Having trouble seeing this email? View the most recent issue or stories from previous issues.
ArcaMax Publishing, Inc.
  Today's Wine & Dine Daily Video
What Makes A Great Recipe?
Play Now!
Advice from Carolyn Hax ArcaMax.com | News | Books | Comics | Games | Subscribe | My Account
 

Travel
For You
Saturday October 31, 2009

Tarmac Delays Ground the Fight for Passenger Rights

By Christopher Elliott, Tribune Media Services

The approach of cold-weather season reminds me of tarmac delays.

Like the Northwest Airlines flights grounded during a 1999 blizzard at Detroit's Metro Airport, leaving passengers without water or working toilets for more than seven hours. Or the JetBlue Airways customers stranded for nearly half a day during an ice storm in New York back in 2007.

But what if those were the only memories that cold weather evoked?

No skiing. No eggnog. No chestnuts roasting on the open fire. That would be absurd, wouldn't it?

No more absurd than what has happened to the "passenger rights movement." In the past few months, a series of headline-grabbing tarmac delays has helped a couple of influential lobbyists convince the media and a few elected officials that tarmac delays are the No. 1 passenger rights problem in America.

Worse, they've convinced many travelers that tarmac delays are the only important passenger rights issue.

Don't believe me? Pull up any recent story that mentions a passenger's bill of rights, and it will inevitably refer to a proposal that would require a plane to turn back after a three-hour ground delay. I happen to disagree that such legislation would help anyone or that it could even be properly enforced, but that's beside the point.

The bigger question is whether this tunnel vision is helping the cause of airline passengers -- and how it might affect your next flight.

I think it goes without saying that other, far more important passenger issues are being overlooked. But I'll say it anyway: We're missing a lot. I asked author and consumer advocate Edward Hasbrouck to name his hot-button passenger rights issues, and alas, tarmac delays didn't make the list. What did? Truth in advertising, problems with federal pre-emption and failure to enforce existing consumer laws.

"Airlines routinely engage in practices that would constitute fraud if engaged in by any other business," he told me. For example, they sell tickets on partner airlines, giving the appearance that they are operating a flight, which is referred to as code-sharing.

Federal pre-emption of consumer protection laws, which allows airlines to ignore state consumer laws and consumer protection agencies, is another worry. The Airline Deregulation Act of 1978 opened that loophole, "and it has been a disaster for consumers," says Hasbrouck.

The U.S. Transportation Department's lack of involvement in consumer protection also ranks as a favorite, and it's an area of concern for me as a reader advocate. The way Hasbrouck sees it, the department is staffed by devout believers in a hands-off approach toward regulation and, specifically, enforcing consumer protections. "Those attitudes have got to go, which is unlikely to happen unless the people at the DOT get firm new marching orders from their superiors, either from the secretary of transportation or President Obama," he says.

Unlike tarmac delays, which affect a tiny fraction of air travelers, these issues factor prominently into everyone's flight. And that they are being ignored raises the question of who really benefits from the popular emphasis on aircraft delays, apart from a few media-savvy tarmac-delay activists.

I'm willing to bet that my friends in the airline industry, who insist that they oppose the new turn-back law, are quietly pleased that the tarmac lobby has hijacked the passenger rights cause. The movement is now conveniently contained, holding sparsely attended news conferences and pep rallies for passenger rights "stakeholders" in the Rayburn House Office Building.

That's not to say that the tarmac troopers don't have a valid point. There's no excuse for keeping a plane waiting for hours without giving passengers food or water. Anyone who has endured an extended delay on a plane can be forgiven for thinking it's the only thing that matters.

In the meantime, what do you do if you're stuck on a parked aircraft? Oddly, the media reports I've seen have fixated on the likelihood that a turn-back law will be passed -- it has a snowball's chance, in case you were wondering -- but have skipped the part where they help us actually fix the problem.

I had an enlightening conversation with Deborah McElroy, the executive vice president in charge of policy and external affairs at the Airports Council International-North America, an airport trade group, about the remedies available to stranded passengers. There are not many.

I've been asked whether there's an easy way off a parked plane, such as calling 911 and complaining that you're being held prisoner. McElroy said emergency calls are routed to local law enforcement agencies, which may pass your complaint along to airport police, but neither is likely to have the authority to force a jet to return. "Only the airport's federal security director, who is a (Transportation Security Administration) employee, has the legal right to order the plane back to the gate," she told me. You may be better off asking a crewmember for help or, failing that, calling the airline.

Would a turn-back rule change anything? It might, she said. It might not. Meaning that the true cost of a passenger's bill of rights may not be just an unenforceable law, but also a long period of distraction from the truly important issues facing passengers.

========

Christopher Elliott is the ombudsman for National Geographic Traveler magazine. You can read more travel tips on his blog, elliott.org or e-mail him at celliott@ngs.org.

Comment on this Story | Printer Friendly | | Send Story to a Friend | Top

Happy Halloween from ArcaMax!

Whether you're taking your kids out trick-or-treating, going out to a party, or staying at home and relaxing, ArcaMax wishes you a safe and happy Halloween!

Before this evening, check out free recipes for treats like pumpkin cupcakes, information on trick-or-treating safety, and more.

Visit the ArcaMax Halloween feature before it disappears!

-- From the ArcaMax editors

Today's Reader Submitted Photos


Click an image above to see full size and read caption.

To see more of our subscriber photos visit our full Photo Gallery.



Enter your Travel pictures so you can show them off to other readers right here in this ezine and on the ArcaMax.com Web site. Click here to submit your photo.

Sincerely,
ArcaMax Editors



Advertisement

NEW Glade Scented Oil Candles:
- FREE* SAMPLE!

Try all the difference scents:
Spiced Rose Vanilla, Orchid Oasis or Dewberry Dreams!

Get Your Glade Scented Oil SAMPLE Now:

Click here...

Recent Stories
Small Arrow   Need a Perfect Travel Bag? The LeSportsac Weekender is the Answer
Small Arrow   Need a Perfect Travel Bag? The LeSportsac Weekender is the Answer
Small Arrow   Spiritual Vacations - A New Hype?
Small Arrow   Spiritual Vacations - A New Hype?
Small Arrow   Around The World: Halloween Encounters At America's Most Haunted Hotels
 
More From ArcaMax Publishing

Newsletters: Comics - Knowledge - Lifestyles - News - More

Classic Books: Fiction - Non Fiction - Short Stories - Sci Fi - More

More: Quizzes - Sudoku - Crossword - Weather - Sports - Columns

En Español: Ultimas Noticias - Tiras Comicas - Deportes - Sudoku

Ad Free Newsletter
ArcaMax publications are now available in an "advertising-free" format.
Please click here for details.
 
The Perfect Job - Paid Surveys, Focus Groups at Home Now You Can Get Paid To: * Take online surveys * Participate in focus groups * Try & Keep new products * Preview movie trailers Top dollar!  Click here now to find out more!
 
Quick Clicks
Book hotel & air together to save up to 30%! Search now!
"How To Send Your Child To College For Free or Close To It"
Get A Years Supply of FREE Diapers - Pick your favorite here
 
Why pay over $90.00 a month for cable or Satellite TV services? Download an extra TV now!  Our software turns your PC into a TV! Go here to find out more
 
Sponsored Articles
spanish wordLearn Spanish with the "Spanish Word of the Day"
Baltimore puts heroes and geniuses together
Age 55 or older? Pay 75%25 less for your cruise
 

Manage Your Subscriptions

You are currently subscribed as duncanjax@gmail.com.
To unsubscribe from this newsletter, please notify us here or visit https://www.arcamax.com/cgi-bin/custacct.

ArcaMax Publishing, Inc., 729 Thimble Shoals Blvd., Suite 1-B, Newport News, VA 23606 | FAX (757) 596-9731
Copyright © 2009 ArcaMax Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Advertise With Us | Contact the Editor | FAQ/Help


ArcaMax Publishing websites:
www.arcamax.com (Family-Friendly News & Fun)
www.bookdaily.com (Book Samples for Book Lovers)
www.arcamundo.com (en español)

No comments:

Post a Comment